
Unknown artist. Greensboro Art Gallery, June 2003
My dear Arizaphale,
Many thanks for your thoughtful email about my blogpost on the outing of Reverend Haggart.
I worried that the personal philosophies which only blogs seem able to reveal would lead us into such a place. Belief is so very central to the core of one's being, that any discussion of it runs the risk of sounding like an attack on the believer himself. A good argument to keep one's religion a private affair. ("So, go on, HH. Throw yours out on the internet, why don't you?")
But remember, I was raised a Catholic. My birth-church was as close as one could come to a factory for atheists. Those who remain Catholics are tortured souls. Or, to use existentialist language, they live in very, very bad faith, indeed.
Rest assured, I am a political atheist rather than a theological one. Living in America again has kicked me up the ass (read arse to you quaint English types) when it comes to belief.
For the record:
- I believe in the persistence of the soul. I felt it. My father. His mother. My maternal grandfather. And his wife, my grandmother, whose weight of scorn I feel every day I need to trot off to Al-Anon meetings. Lord Denning's mother, whom I knew. Even--nay, especially--our friends the father and son who died within a month of each other.
- I believe that the glorious randomness of the universe sometimes, when truly allowed to act at random, doesn't act at random at all. Too many spooky coincidences, too much serendipity, too much human progress for there not to be some positive energy driving it. (That's not the same as God-capital-G, I hasten to add.)
- I believe that much of the bible (both testaments) is gibberish.
In gentler times, I guess I would have been called a secularist, a humanist, or if I had to be churched, a Unitarian Universalist. (My high school deputy headmistress died in office, as it were, and she was a Unitarian. I attended her memorial service. The dignity moved me.)
I agree with your point: a clever God could create evolution. In fact, He probably did.
If a scientist looks at evolution, he notes plenty of evidence for it. It does, indeed, work as science describes. Few, though, venture an explanation about how it seems to work so quickly--which, I understand, it does.
Some other energy is at work apart from sheer chance. But that energy works through the mechanism of chance, rather than through direct intervention--the parts of the bible in which god speaks directly or intervenes in earthly affairs, well, that's something I can't believe.
If there is a God, the mechanism of chance and coincidence is how He works; no wonder people say He works in mysterious ways.
Arthur Koestler's
The Roots of Coincidence seems to make a plausible case for this kind of idea, though I don't buy all the rest of the stuff he writes about parapsychology. Better, I've come to know a few people from
Seed Magazine, who maintain that the beauty and passion of scientific discovery has a spiritual quality. An interesting bunch of people.
I believe that. Fine. OK. Sure.
But frankly, in the United States in 2006, that don't amount to nuthin' belief-wise. If you haven't accepted Jesus Christ
(TM) as Your Personal Savior
(TM), you're filthy, godless, and unsaved. An American does not have the luxury of keeping religion a private matter; it's so in-your-face, that saying no-thank-you to the promise of salvation excites distrust, suspicion, and, yes, prejudice.
I call myself a Rationalist. By American standards, though, I'm an atheist. (And a New York registered Democrat, which to middle America, is the same thing)
I have thrown my lot in with the godless and actually attended some political gatherings that support the separation of church and state. And you know what? The atheists I met are more moral than any American Christian (TM) I've met.
(I have accepted the homeless guy on the corner of 46th and 2nd as My Personal Beggar, though. I nearly weaned him off god-blessing me when I give him a buck, but the habit of a lifetime is hard to break.)
In fact, Riz, YOU are the only Christian I know who acknowledges that the Bible contains contradictions. To my mind, that kinda blows its cred, no? Further the Bible seems a pretty poor moral guide to life, especially Leviticus.
Atheism and a belief in the positive energy of the spirit are not incompatible. Just as a belief in the Bible and charity toward homosexuals are not incompatible. (You will explain that one to me, won't you?)
Love you love you love you.
The Honourable Husband